1.17.2008

Scale and Politics

A quick comparative observation: For the last several weeks, I’ve been hearing incessantly about how allowing Iowa and New Hampshire a disproportionate share of influence in U.S. elections (not that it means all that much) is a good thing because it retains the “retail politics” that allows for a personal connection and a chance for the underdog (I guess an exceptionally well-leisured underdog) to get to make an impression on the voters individually.

This seems like another scale / distribution argument. Something like this: Well, if we have a bloated, centralized system where overriding macro-decisions are made by people that have no connection to the life of the average citizen, at least someone gets a chance to actually meet these people and stand in as proxy-average at the manageable scale of, say, a city council election. Seems like a tacit acknowledgement of the problems of centralization and aggregation.

Stupid, arbitrary, and awkward; but I’ll take it over an entirely media-mediated process any day.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home